10 Best Vanilla Extract America’s Test Kitchen of 2021

Tasty and delicious foods come with using the required ingredients. And for people to appreciate and always long for your foods, you need to include vanilla extracts in your cooking.

Vanilla extracts are useful and important recipes used in various like cakes, psalteries etc. But, quality and flavor profile of various kinds of vanilla extracts may sometimes vary widely.

Top 5 Best Vanilla Extract America’s Test Kitchen: Editor Recommended

The market has a wide range of vanilla extracts and if you are not careful, you may need up choosing a wrong vanilla extract. But to help you out, we have prepared a review of the best vanilla extracts.

Our review is detailed to help you avoid the hassles of browsing every site in search of the best.

The 10 Best Vanilla Extract America’s Test Kitchen Reviews:

1. Nielsen-Massey Madagascar Bourbon Pure Vanilla Extract, with Gift Box, 32 ounces


We start with Nielsen-Massey Madagascar Bourbon Pure Vanilla Extract that is no stranger with these products to culinary experts.

Manufactures have added high-quality flavors to these brands, which makes it more preferable above all else. Packed in 32-ounce bottles as a fluid extract, these extracts come with a flavor profile that’s complete, creamy, mellow with velvety after tones.

Free from allergen, and gluten, our top brand makes a preferable product for people who are sensitive to gluten Also, they present pure vanilla tastes and thereby making them best to people who need all-natural extracts.

Moreover, this extract is non-GMO project approved, and kosher verified, which implies that Nielsen-Massey Madagascar is free from harmful substances. Customers who want to complement their sweet dishes like cakes, pastries, and cookies are urged to buy Nielsen-Massy Madagascar Extract.

People who consider these vanilla extracts should ensure they practice required storage habits to maintain in good conditions all through. Nielsen-Massey Madagascar vanilla extracts are best stored at room temperature and in airtight containers.

Additionally, users should add the vanilla content towards the cooking process.


  • Comes with an ideal taste and aroma
  • Has no allergens and gluten
  • All-natural, kosher certified and non-GMO
  • Excellently packed.


  • A bit costly.


2. Watkins All Natural Original Gourmet Baking Vanilla, with Pure Vanilla Extract, 11 ounces Bottle, 1 Count


Next, we have the Watkins is perfectly packed and comes with a lovely bottle 11 oz. to pull interest of prospects. Culinary experts prefer this brand due to its superior and quality flavors and aroma.

Manufacturers make them from pure vanilla extract and all-naturally extracted ingredients. Watkins will transform customers’ cooking and elevate it to the highest form in smell and sweetness.

Manufactured have added special ingredients to their products. Being non-GMO verified, and kosher certified, these extracts prove to be safe to use during baking. Also, this brand is suitable for people who are sensitive to gluten and corn syrup.

Simply the best, have a try of it and testify the results to the prospective buyers who also think of providing them a try.

Consequently, Watkins All Natural Original Gourmet Baking Vanilla extracts are presentations of quality products worthy it in the market.

Made in the USA, manufacturers doesn’t add any artificial flavors or colors in the contents at all. Users should worry less about these products since they are pure and certified for use by the FDA authorities.


  • Free from gluten and corn syrup
  • Non-GMO certified
  • Pure and all natural
  • Free from artificial colors.


  • Many people say it has a strong scent.


3. McCormick All-Natural Pure Vanilla Extract, 16 fl oz

Our third extract offers a pure, natural taste that is pleasant. McCormick All-natural Extract contains no artificial ingredients like sweeteners and does not contain corn syrup, or have they been diluted.

These products are approved by the Non-GMO project. Hence, users get assured that it is as close to nature as possible. People who are allergic to gluten will happily use these type of vanilla extracts.

In fact, these products contain Madagascar vanilla pods, alcohol, and water. Although the alcohol content is not too high, people who are extremely sensitive to alcohol may suffer from the use of this type of vanilla extract.

Since the sugar content in these extracts is minimal, they are great for sweet and savory dishes. Users will find that a little helps a lot. Those who love baking should take advantage of these vanilla extracts to take their preparations in higher levels.

McCormick all-natural pure vanilla extracts helps to enhance flavors not only to baked foods but also marinades, sauces and vinaigrettes. People who are allergic to gluten will happily use these type of vanilla extracts.


  • Lacks a corn syrup
  • A little amount can help a lot
  • Has no artificial ingredients
  • All-natural and has no glutens.


  • Not good for alcoholics.

4. Nielsen-Massey Madagascar Bourbon Pure Vanilla Extract, 4 ounces

People are always impressed with Nielsen-Massey Bourbon Madagascar Pure Vanilla Extracts. These extracts are manufactured from high quality bourbon vanilla pods from Madagascar.

They usually describe the taste profile of these extracts as full, aromatic, creamy and smooth. Usually sourced from Madagascar vanilla, clients get assured of receiving a classic vanilla that they have never experienced before.

Approved by the Non-GMO project, buyers are assured that these extracts are healthy and do not have any traces of pesticides. As a bonus, these extracts have been certified kosher and are gluten-free.

This implies that individuals of all dietary preferences will use these extracts without. Due to its taste, users can only use a small drop, which can last for a long time.

What makes these vanilla extracts stand out is their flavor profile that comprises sweet, mellow and creamy flavors. Manufacturers also make them from all-natural materials to make them ideal for all people.

The ingredients employed to make these vanilla are simply water, vanilla beans and alcohol with content of 35%. They are tasteful and flavor additions worthy to try.


  • A small amount can last a long time
  • Approved by Non-GMO Project.
  • Verified kosher and has no gluten
  • Packed with an ideal gift box.


  • Stopper sticks in cold weather.

5. Simply Organic Pure Vanilla Extract, Certified Organic, 4 oz Glass Bottle (Packaging May Vary)

Here comes the Simply Organic Pure Vanilla Extract neatly packaged and manufactured from the Madagascar Bourbon variety of vanilla beans. Individuals prefer these extracts due to their smooth buttery, sweet taste and subtle floral notes.

Being great presentations of ideal extracts for desserts and sauces, they are perfect options for people who love sugar-free extracts.

Moreover, manufacturers doesn’t include fake colors and flavors when making these extracts. Additionally, these vanilla extracts are QAI certified, kosher accredited, and GMO-free, thereby making them more authentic and safer to use.

They have a deeper amber color, natural sweetness, and rich taste for amazing cooking and baking. Furthermore, the manufacturers carefully process these extracts without the use of harmful pesticides, GMOs and radiation, making them healthy solutions.

Manufactured in Madagascar, raw materials employed in the formulation comes from small-scale farmers. Production relationship of these vanilla extracts starts from the growers’ side to ensure only quality and pure products get produced.

The production room is also environmental friendly thereby yielding only high-quality extracts. Taste the feeling of the vanilla extracts from Madagascar and testify the experience to other prospective buyers.


  • Lacks allergens
  • Packed perfectly well
  • Incredible sweetness and flavor
  • GMO and sugar-free.


  • A lot of alcohol
  • Customers complain of their diluted nature.


6. Rodelle Gourmet Pure Vanilla Extract, 8 Oz

Are you looking for affordable organic vanilla extract to enrich your preparations at home? Now, Rodelle Gourmet Pure Vanilla Extract is a super affordable pure vanilla extract worthy to try.

Manufacturers make these extracts from three ingredients, and they have no sugar content in them. Rodelle Gourment gets manufactured from quality ingredients, and thereby making it suitable for those who are sensitive to gluten.

Having the Kosher certification, these vanilla extracts are true presentations of quality products in the market. Moreover, Rodelle Gourmet vanilla extracts are perfect products for those who need to enhance all of their baked goods.

Additionally, these are quality products for people who yearn to use gluten-free vanilla extracts. Consequently, where these vanilla extracts get manufactured is a show that only quality products comes out for sale.

Rodelle pure vanilla extracts gets manufactured in facilities powered by Northern Colorado winds. Such an environment means only quality and healthy extracts come out for use.

Ingredients employed in the formulation of these extracts includes alcohol content and the Vala bean attractiveness in water. If you need to enrich your meals with excellent flavors, then have it a try with the Rodelle Gourmet vanilla extracts.


  • Affordable
  • Packed with a stylish box
  • Gluten-free
  • Made from high-quality ingredients.


  • Lack good smell.

7. Nielsen-Massey Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla Extract, 8 Ounces

Another vanilla extracts from Nielsen-Massey, and it’s the ideal all-purpose vanilla. Accessed from Madagascar, the Nielsen-massy bourbon vanilla extract is natural grown with no GMO projects, no traces of gluten, and allergen.

Having the Kosher certification, these extracts make suitable products for people who are sensitive to all these substances. Moreover, they make the perfect solutions for people in need to complement a variety of recipes, ranging from savory to baked foods.

What makes the Nielsen-Massey Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla Extract is its full flavor profile. They include creamy and mellow flavors with velvety after-tones on consumers’ tongues, making their taste buds want more.

Some ingredients included in these brands include vanilla bean extractives, water, sugar, and 35% alcohol content.

Like other vanilla extracts around, excellent storage practices means a lot to continue getting the taste from them. These extracts are best stored at room temperature and in airtight containers.

Nevertheless, you will work towards achieving the best results and excellent aroma in all your daily kitchen preparations. Achieving this requires users to apply Nielsen-Massey Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla Extract towards the end of the cooking process.


  • Extremely well-packed
  • Free from GMOs
  • Gluten and allergen-free
  • Quality vanilla flavor


  • Quite expensive

8. Native Vanilla All Natural Pure Vanilla Extract 4 oz Made from Premium Vanilla Bean Pods


Chefs like Native Vanilla Extract due to its rich flavor that can retain around 300 compound flavors. Most people have reported that the Native Vanilla extracts have a unique taste that is worth enjoying.

And as the name suggests, Native Vanilla is completely natural and contains no additives, wrong flavors, sugar, or coloring. People who are sensitive to sugar have found the most suitable and tastiest brand.

Native Vanilla — All Natural Pure Vanilla Extract is kosher certified thereby taking a step to present a few of the quality extracts around. Moreover, vegetarians should take advantage of this vanilla extracts since it has a vegan certification.

You don’t have to use the extract excessively to attain a flavor, just a tablespoonful amount is enough for excellent results. Unlike other brands that come diluted, these are strong to enable you to use low amounts and gets a top flavor.

Native Vanilla Extracts are great representations of quality and healthy extracts that people have tasted and provided them an excellent rating.

Their production includes the use of organic materials obtained from farmers committed to growing their products with environmentally friendly practices. Users are assured of a quality product to take their recipes to top levels.


  • High-quality vanilla flavor
  • Kosher accredited
  • Affordable
  • Sugar-free


  • Not well-packed

9. Nielsen-Massey Pure Vanilla Extract, with Gift Box, 32 ounces

Here again, we present another vanilla extract from Nielsen-Massey that has proved of providing excellent flavor to kitchen preparations. Bakers and chefs like Nielsen-Massey Pure Vanilla Extract due to the tasty and sweet flavor it offers.

Made from strict and unwavering standards, these vanilla extracts can be used in many foods like sweet treats to savory meals. Nielsen-Massey Pure vanilla extract is GMO-free, kosher approved, and free from gluten.

With these features, people sensitive to gluten can use this product. Manufacturers employ a blend of selective beans from farmers to ensure they come out with extracts that provide excellent results.

Moreover, the Nielsen-Massey manufacturers follow strict standards and guidelines to construct their vanilla extracts for quality assurance purposes.

The manufacturing process entails a cold extraction routine that keeps the compounds intact to ensure what comes contains rich flavors. These vanilla extracts have over 300 flavor compounds best for several foods, even the savory dishes and sweet treats alike.

Ingredients employed to formulate these vanilla extracts include sugar, alcohol, vanilla bean extractives, and water. Taste them and testify your experience to prospective buyers who need to give them a try.


  • All-natural and GMO-free
  • Extremely well packaged
  • Allergen-free
  • Kosher certified


  • Expensive for many people

10. Watkins Organic Pure Vanilla Extract, with Madagascar Vanilla Beans, 4 oz. Bottle, 3-Pack

We won’t complete the review without having a touch of vanilla extracts that boasts trendy flavors. Watkins Pure Organic Vanilla Extracts produce a pure flavor made with natural flavors in trendy flavors.

This brand is widely known to customers for the quality of its ingredients and attention to detail. It’s a perfect extract for desserts, drinks, and more.

Made from natural oils, they don’t have any artificial colors and flavors. This makes them save to use, and a small amount can last long due to their quality flavors. Individuals who are allergic to gluten will find this product more impressive.

Like other vanilla extracts, you find in the market, these products are USDA certified for being on the list of quality and organic options around. Being non-GMO verified market brands, they make the perfect solutions for people who love gluten-free extracts.

Moreover, Watkins Pure Organic Vanilla Extracts are Kosher certified and corn syrup-free products. The contents don’t contain any artificial colors, flavors and thereby making them quality and healthy products worthy to consider.


  • A small amount goes a long way
  • Doesn’t have any artificial ingredients
  • Lacks corn syrup
  • More natural and doesn’t have gluten


  • Not great for people sensitive to alcohol

Buying Guide: What to Consider When Choosing The Best Vanilla Extract

Best Vanilla Extract

We have several extract brands and types in the market serving a similar purpose. As a buyer, you need to sieve through the long list and decide on a single option that will serve your intended need.

Ensure you do the selection perfectly to avoid getting stuck while busy following your recipes closely. Keep these factors in mind to enable you to purchase a quality extract that serves your need.

a) Ingredients

Most vanilla extract-making companies employ sugars and other additives to make their products. This is great since they contribute greatly to the affordability of the product.

However, sugar and other additives in vanilla extracts lower their quality at a higher percentage. When purchasing these products, you must look for purely extracted products.

Ensure that what you choose get created from vanilla beans that are grown without employing chemical agents. But how would you determine that your extract was purely made?

For this, you will look at whether what you choose has a certification of being a non-GMO product. Get something that won’t give you any effect or to your loved ones after use.

b) Strength

Vanilla extract manufacturers make products of both standard and strong strength to fit different market prospects. Others love a slight vanilla extract while others love it when strongest.

However, we advise prospective buyers to choose strong options since they provide rich flavors. Moreover, strong vanilla extracts provide an opportunity to use less to get the flavor they need.

c) Cost of Vanilla Extract

Lastly, you should mind the cost of vanilla extract you intend to purchase before paying for the product. Get an idea of the price tag of each bottle and try to find out whenever there is a difference.

After noting the cost, does the seller’s price tag correlate with the quality and flavor of the vanilla extract? Ensure you compare all the aspects well before you consider a particular product.


Vanilla extracts are a necessity to chefs who need their loved ones to enjoy delicious preparations all day. Since we have different types around, it is critical when selecting what to purchase.

However, that should not give you a headache since the review has provided you a solution. Our review has provided a clue of the top vanilla extracts prospective buyers should consider when purchasing these products.

Additionally, we have provided a few factors that enable buyers to cancel out the long list to get the best overall. Employ the ideas above, and you won’t regret it after making a selection.

Source Link


Leave a Comment