10 Best Roasting Pan America’s Test Kitchen of 2021

We all love roast meat, and enjoying it in our apartments requires us to upgrade our kitchens with essential roasting appliances. Roasting pans are a few inexpensive and versatile appliances meat lovers should not lack in their kitchens.

These appliances enable us to enjoy the stylish and delicious roast meat from our apartments’ comfort. But what are the best roasting pans worthy of purchasing? Now, with several roasting pans available in the market, most buyers find it hard to select the best of all.

Top 5 Best Roasting Pan America’s Test Kitchen: Editor Recommended

However, if you still struggle in choosing the best roasting pan, continue reading this review. We present the top-notch roasting pans proved to offer excellent service. Our buying guide will also help buyers narrow the big lists they have to settle for an appropriate model.

The 10 Best Roasting Pan America’s Test Kitchen Reviews:

We have quite a lot of roasting pan models in the market competing for space. Only the best ones will take over and attain a high demand for customers all over. But which are the current big wigs in this industry?

Below are the top ten roasting pans worthy of considering when purchasing them.

1. Circulon Nonstick Roasting Pan / Roaster with Rack — 17 Inch x 13 Inch, Gray

Circulon Nonstick Roasting Pan
  • EXTRA LARGE ROASTING PAN WITH RACK: 17 inch x 13 inch Nonstick Oven...
  • DURABLE ROASTER RACK: The roaster features a convenient U-shaped rack...
  • FAST AND EVEN HEATING: Nonstick roaster features heavy duty steel...
  • SUPERIOR NONSTICK: Superior nonstick technology provides excellent...

People have tested Circulon Nonstick Roasting Pans and testified their superiority in the kitchen. Their construction incorporates heavy-duty steel materials that provide even heat distribution throughout the roasting process.

Circulon Nonstick Roasting Pans also feature large capacities to hold big roasts and birds alike. Moreover, these pans have racks that enable continuous heat flow underneath for fast and even roasting.

As an excellent performer, these pans feature U-shaped racks that keep your roast off the base. They employ non-stick technology in their design for easy food release as well as an easy cleaning process.

Consequently, the manufacturer considered constructing them with wide handles to provide users excellent and confident grip. With heat resistance of up to 450 degrees F, the Circulon Nonstick model forms ideal roasting pans worthy of trying.


  • Sturdy models
  • Easy to clean
  • Great sizes
  • Excellent performers in the kitchen


  • Rusts faster
  • Not appealing

Buy on Amazon

2. GreenPan Padova Reserve Healthy Ceramic Nonstick Roasting Pan, 13″ x 16″, Black

GreenPan Padova Reserve
  • GreenPan’s Thermolon healthy ceramic nonstick coating is free of...
  • Metal utensil safe, this collection's diamond-reinforced coating is...
  • Hard anodized aluminum body is unbelievably durable and...
  • Oven and broiler safe up to 600°F

Health-wise, GreenPan Padova Reserve Healthy Roasting Pans makes the safest options worthy of the value. Constructed with a ceramic nonstick coat, this material is free of PFOA, cadmium, PFEAS, and lead.

Manufacturers provide users 100% assurance of no release of harmful substances even if subjected to high temperatures. Moreover, their versatility is unbeatable; these roasting pans combat all stovetops available except for induction.

GreenPan Padova Roasting Pans stand out due to their durability and overall heat resistance rate. Rated at 600 degrees F oven and boiler safe, manufacturers construct their bodies using hard-anodized aluminum for extra durability.

In addition, the material used to build the body boast scratch resistance feature to maintain their excellent look most extended. Like their competitors, these roasting pans feature V-shaped racks to maintain the roasts off from the base.

With these pans, users have the assurance of continuous heating without energy loss. Nevertheless, GreenPan Padova Roasting Pans have gold-tone and sleek handles that provide uses excellent grip. Lastly, you can clean your pan easily in a dishwasher after use.


  • Backed with a limited lifetime warranty
  • Great quality
  • Safest options
  • Easy to use and clean


  • Handles not strong
  • Poor customer support

Buy on Amazon

3. Cuisinart Chef’s Classic Stainless 16-Inch Rectangular Roaster with Rack, Roaster Rack

Product Name
  • EXCEPTIONAL DESIGN: The Cuisinart 16-inch rectangular roaster is made...
  • STURDY & STRONG: A sturdy rack with stainless steel handles allows...
  • MEASUREMENTS: Pan measurements: 16.8” Length, 12.8” Width, 3.4”...
  • WARRANTY: Lifetime warranty

People intending to purchase roasting pans that can hold large roasts should consider these models their best choice. Cuisinart Roasting Pans form the perfect cookware for those who organize family dinners and other forms of celebrations.

Measuring 12. 8″ W x16. 8″ L x3. 4″H, these pans can hold turkeys, big birds, and other large roasts. Another fantastic thing the Cuisinart Roasting Pans feature is their comfortable handles.

They have riveted handles constructed using stainless steel to make lifting into and out of ovens safe. Moreover, they employ the heat surround technology to ensure there is even heat distribution to provide perfect roasts.

Consequently, they also feature stainless steel racks for proper heat circulation during the roasting process. Their professional exterior construction makes the cleaning process a breeze. Users can either wash them by hand or in dishwashers after use or before storing them.


  • Large capacities
  • Excellent and comfortable grip
  • Easy to use and clean
  • Roasts food materials excellently


  • Aren’t suitable on stovetops
  • Interior surface damaged

Buy on Amazon

4. Roasting Pan with Rack, P&P CHEF 14 Inch Stainless Steel Roaster Lasagna Pan 

Roasting Pan with Rack
  • 【HEALTHY】Both the roasting pan and rack are made of 100% pure...
  • 【EASY CLEAN】 Roaster pan and racks are dishwasher safe without...
  • 【ROASTING PAN】Two wider and rigid handles riveted firmly, For a...
  • 【TWO RACKS】The thick and sturdy parallel wires and elevated feet...

Here come another safe and healthiest roasting pans that are durable and hold heavy foods. Construction of these pans and the racks incorporate pure stainless steel that doesn’t emit toxins even in high temperatures.

They measure 15.7×10.6×5.5 inches, and they form perfect models for a variety of applications, both roasting, cooking veggies, and baking.  P&P CHEF 14 Inch Stainless Steel Roasters have two riveted handles to provide users excellent and comfortable grip.

Apart from the handles, they also feature a 3.7-inch rim that prevents messy sauce spills during the cooking period. In addition, they have round edges purposely for maximum protection when cleaning them.

You can wash your roasting pan either in a dishwasher or by hand using soapy water. What makes them unmatched are the double racks the manufacturer includes in their construction.

These racks offer excellent support to the heavy stuff as they ensure there is even heat distribution for perfect roasting. There is also a V-shaped rack for separate cooking, and they offer excellent crisping as well as browning.


  • Easy to use
  • Very sturdy and durable
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Ultra-durable


  • Very small
  • Handles heat up

Buy on Amazon

5. Mr Rudolf 17 inch Roasting Pan with Lid and Rack

Mr Rudolf 17 inch Roasting Pan
  • Superior Cooking Surface: The 18/10 Mirror finish stainless steel...
  • Unsurpassed Heat Distribution: Triple-Ply construction aluminum...
  • Drip-Free Pouring & Dishwasher Safe: Rim is smoothly tapered to...
  • Solid stainless steel welding handles make placing the roasters into...

As the most versatile roasting pans available, Mr Rudolf’s pans work perfectly in all conventional stovetops and induction stoves. Manufacturers design these roasting pans using an 18/10 mirror exterior stainless steel finish that doesn’t alter the food flavor.

What makes them stand out of the market models are their triple-ply constructed bases. These roasting pans have aluminum encapsulated bases that enable the fast and even distribution of heat to cook foodstuffs perfectly.

Consequently, Mr Rudolf 17 inch Roasting Pans also have smoothly tapered rims to prevent messy spills and drips while pouring. Nevertheless, Mr Rudolf’s roasting pans feature stainless steel lacks efficient air circulation throughout the roasting process.

Their handles are also excellent and comfortable; they make lifting stuff in and out of ovens easy and safe. In addition, cleaning them to attain their original look is also a breeze to these roasting pans. Their premium stainless steel material is easy to clean using soapy water.


  • Backed by a limited lifetime warranty
  • Good quality models
  • Excellent handles
  • Safe options for use


  • Not the actual size
  • Difficult to clean

Buy on Amazon

6. Mr Rudolf 15 inch Roasting Pan with Lid and Rack

Mr Rudolf 15 inch Roasting Pan
  • Superior Cooking Surface: The 18/10 Mirror finish stainless steel...
  • Unsurpassed Heat Distribution: Triple-Ply construction aluminum...
  • Drip-Free Pouring & Dishwasher Safe: Rim is smoothly tapered to...
  • Solid stainless steel welding handles make placing the roasters into...

Here come the second Mr Rudolf models are known for their superior 18/10 stainless steel finish that doesn’t alter flavors. Like their brothers Mr Rudolf 17 inch roasting pans, these models feature triple-ply aluminum encapsulated constructed bases for even heat distribution.

Mr Rudolf 15 inch Roasting Pans reduces heat hotspots to ensure your foodstuffs heats up perfectly and quickly. Consequently, their rims are smoothly tapered to prevent messy spills and drips when pouring foodstuffs. Lifting of roasts in and out of the oven is also a breeze using their stainless steel grippy handles.

Nevertheless, these models also have stainless steel racks for efficient heat circulation. For cleaning, their premium stainless steel material will attain its original appearance with just a single wash.


  • No accidental spills
  • Excellent performers
  • Easy to lift and transfer
  • Simple to clean


  • Not actual size as advertised
  • Quality issues

Buy on Amazon

7. Rachael Ray Bakeware Nonstick Roaster/Roasting Pan 

Rachael Ray Bakeware Nonstick Roaster
  • BIG ROASTING PAN: Large, sturdy, durable steel roasting pan with...
  • NONSTICK ROASTER SET: Roasting pan and reversible rack feature...
  • EASY HANDLING: Wide roasting pan handles offer a comfy grip, even with...
  • VERSATILE DESIGN: Roasting pan set is oven safe to 450 degrees F for a...

Leave the above roasting pans if you are looking for a big as well as versatile option. Rachael Ray Bakeware pans forms the perfect durable and multi-purpose roasters for beef, turkeys, and chicken.

With a capacity of up to 20lb, these roasting pans also make the ideal options for casseroles and lasagna. Like other roasting pans in the market, these models feature nonstick surfaces for easy food release.

Lifting foodstuffs in and out of ovens is simple with these roasting pans. Manufacturers construct them with wide handles that provide excellent grip even when using them as turkey pans.

Consequently, with a heat resistance of 450 degrees F, these roasting pans can handle various roasting recipes. They stand out with their HI-LO reversible racks that sit flat or elevated to provide room for other separate stuff. Lastly, their nonstick surfaces enable users to clean them easily after use.


  • Lightweight models
  • Easy to clean
  • Sturdy models
  • Excellent and comfortable handling


  • The Teflon peels off faster
  • Scratches easily

Buy on Amazon

8. Ceramic Coated Roasting Pan / Lasagna Pan

Ceramic Coated Roasting Pan
  • Made IN Italy gourmet quality: Professional-grade, ceramic-coated pan...
  • Safe Eco-friendly materials: We use only PTFE-free, cadmium-free, and...
  • Oven-safe: Sear steaks, roasts, chicken, veggies & more on the...
  • Superior European made quality and design

Made to last long, these roasting pans serve as a few of the safes options around that doesn’t react with food. Manufacturers construct them using eco-friendly materials that are free of Lead, PTFE, and cadmium.

Also, they design the bases using a thick 2.5 mm aluminum that heats quickly to facilitate fast cooking. Moreover, the quality ceramic coat used to create the body ensures even heat distribution throughout the cooking process.

Ceramic Coated Roasting Pans stand out due to their scratch-resistance feature that adds up to their overall durability. You can employ them for various applications, including searing steaks, veggies, chicken, and other roasts.

Cooking can start on stovetops, and you can afterward transfer ready stuff to the oven for additional flavor. As proof of quality construction, manufacturers back them with a year return warranty for any form of issue.


  • Safest roasting pans
  • Easy to clean
  • Excellent quality
  • Solid and sturdy


  • Easily warps on stovetops
  • Sharp edges

Buy on Amazon

9. Mr Captain Roasting Pan with Rack and Lid 12 Quart

Mr Captain Roasting Pan
  • SUPERIOR COOKING SURFACE-The 18/10 roasting pans stainless steel...
  • EVEN HEAT DISTRIBUTION: Triple-Ply construction aluminum encapsulated...
  • SOLID DESIGN: Solid stainless steel welding handles make placing the...
  • DRIP-FREE POURING & DISHWASHER SAFE: Rim is smoothly tapered to...

At 24 pounds, Mr Captain Pans are the heaviest ultra-large models for cooking large meats and heavy turkeys. Manufacturers construct these pans using 18/10 stainless steel materials that don’t react or alter food flavor.

Moreover, they have triple-ply bases made of aluminum material for fast heating as well as even distribution of heat. What makes these pans unmatched is their versatility; they combat all stoves, including stovetops, grills, induction cookers, and ovens.

Another greatness in them is their solid handles that make the transfer of foodstuffs safe and simple. Consequently, Mr Captain Pans have solid racks that enable efficient circulation of heat throughout the cooking process.

Seemingly, these pans are also the easiest to clean. Their construction incorporates premium stainless steel that is easy to clean. Nevertheless, they have smoothly tapered rims to prevent the spilling of contents from the pan. You can clean your roaster pan by hand or using a dishwasher.


  • Designed using durable material
  • Easy to use
  • Multi-functional models
  • Ultra-durable


  • Surface reacts with food
  • Stained faster

Buy on Amazon

10. Viking Culinary 40051-9902C Roasting Pan, 16″ x 13″ X 3″, Black

Viking Culinary 40051-9902C Roasting Pan
  • Includes Roasting Pan with Rack and 2-Piece Carving Set
  • The Hard Anodized design features an aluminum layer having gone...
  • Easily holds up to a 25-pound Turkey so whether you are cooking for a...
  • Signature Viking handles feature a heat brake for Stay-Cool cooking...

Our last roasting pans, the Viking Culinary 40051-9902C, takes this slot due to their heavy-duty design. Buyers can employ them to cook large roast meat, chicken, and also vegetables alike.

Apart from their heavy-duty state, most people prefer them since they work excellently on all cooktops. Their 500 degrees F heat resistance rate makes them ideal for use in ovens without worries.

What makes them exemplary is their triple-layer nonstick PFOA-free interior for safety purposes and easy food release. Manufacturers design these pans using hard-anodized material to provide long-lasting services.

These materials also ensure there is even heat distribution for users to get perfect roasts. Moreover, the Viking Culinary 40051-9902C pans have riveted handles to provide users optimum comfort and balance when cooking foodstuffs.


  • Sturdy and ultra-durable models
  • Easy to clean
  • Compatible with all stovetops
  • Excellent and comfortable grip


  • Wrong dimensions
  • Not dishwasher safe

Buy on Amazon

Buying Guide: What to Consider When Shopping The Best Roasting Pan

Purchasing the best roasting pan involves a lot of research as well as careful thinking. You need to make a comparison of the available models to settle on the best overall.

Best Roasting Pan

However, that is not a simple task if you have no idea going about the selection process. Below are factors prospective buyers should employ to purchase a roasting pan of value.

a) Size

The first thing that roles in people’s minds when purchasing roasting pans are the size aspect. Remember, you need a pan that can hold roasts that will serve the number of people around.

If you are preparing for a particular event, get a pan that will accommodate a big roast to serve your multitude. Those looking for pans that can hold food for their families can opt for medium or smaller options.

Others will roast their birds and foodstuffs on stovetops or grill and complete in ovens. Such instances require you to mind the dimension of your oven before purchasing a pan. Overall, buyers should only purchase roasting pans that can accommodate enough food they intend to cook.

b) Material

Roasting pans manufacturers employ different materials to construct their models. The commonly used materials are stainless steel and carbon steel. However, others get designed of enameled cast iron and nonstick materials as such.

All these materials have their greatness, and buyers should set their priorities in the selection process. Others offer excellent appearances, easy to clean, great heat conductors, and many other benefits. Every buyer should decide what they need from their purchase for them to make an informed decision.

c) Features

Everybody tends to look at roasting pans’ features and compare them before they can decide what to purchase. Features like, for instance, grippy handles, the inclusion of lids, and racks are important in constructing these appliances. They all have benefits alike and play a role in the performance of pans.

Likewise, other roasting pans might lack these features. When selecting a roasting pan, settle on featured models if you need to get the best results. For instance, you need a pan with grippy handles for comfortable and secure handling. Get a pan that promises the best results throughout the cooking process and its entire life.


Roasting pans are must-have kitchen appliances in our homes and also restaurants all over for delicious roasts. They are an excellent kitchen upgraders for those who need to take their kitchen experiences higher. However, not all roasting pans over the shelves can satisfy your needs.

You need to research the options that go by what you intend to do with a roasting pan. The product review above provides the limelight of the top-notch roasting pans we have around. They are all worthy of purchasing to any chef who needs the best results in the kitchen.

Alongside there is a shopping guide that helps buyers compare the products to settle on the best roasting pan. Prospective buyers should incorporate the ideas for them to choose a pan they won’t ever regret about.

Source Link


Leave a Comment