10 Best Pizza Stone America’s Test Kitchen of 2021 – Review and Buying Guide

Homemade pizzas are an excellent substitute for regular takeout and one of the best ways to get your family’s favorite meal on the table. The only problem is that finding that crusty texture can be a little bit tricky.

If it’s your first time making pizza at home, getting one of the best pizza stones in the market might be all that you need to get that crusty crunch.

For starters, pizza stones refer to a flat ceramic heat-conducting slab for baking pizza.

Top 5 Best Pizza Stone America’s Test Kitchen: Editor Recommended

We understand that it’s easy for one to “drown” in the ocean of pizza stone choices in the marketplace, so we’ve compiled one of the best reviews to help you identify the perfect pizza stone for all your kitchen needs.

The 10 Best Pizza Stone America’s Test Kitchen Reviews:

Apart from just giving you an inside look at the top 10 best pizza stones available today, we’ve additionally added a quick buying guide to make sure that you’ll end up getting value for your hard-earned money.

Let’s dig in.

1. CastElegance 14-inch Round Thermarite Pizza Stone

Sale
CastElegance 14-inch Round Thermarite
  • Crispiest Crust: Make the perfect restaurant quality pizza at home...
  • Extreme Durability: Thermarite is durable, strong, and has superior...
  • Certified Safe: Odorless and food safe, with easy clean up and...
  • Cook Anywhere: Our stone has superior heat retention and can be used...

Rated as one of Amazon’s #1 bestselling pizza grilling stones, the CastElegance 14-inch Round Thermarite Pizza Stone weighs 5.66 pounds and measures 14 x 14 x 0.63 inches.

For crispy-crunchy pizzas, CastElegance’s thermarite-made pizza stone comes with exceptional heating capabilities. Sample features being efficient heat conduction, heat retention, and moisture absorption. Thermarite-made pizza stones are usually durable, meaning that you’ll be using them for quite a long while.

CastElegance 14-inch Round Thermarite Pizza Stone generally has perfect thermal shock capabilities, and you can cook with it from anywhere, but ovens and grills are preferable.

What I love more about it is that it does not release any foul smell when heated, implying that it’s very safe for home cooking. The extra eBook and scraper included with the package give users a quick head start, especially when making the crispiest homemade pizza for dinner with less effort.

Pros

  • High heat conductivity
  • Excellent thermal shock ability
  • Highly durable
  • Includes an eBook and a scrapper

Cons

  • Odor problems

Buy on Amazon

2. The 16” Honey-Can-Do Pizza Stone

Honey-Can-Do Pizza Stone
  • Makes restaurant quality pizzas, bread, pastries and vegetables
  • Durable, non-cracking; crafted from a blend of lead-free clays
  • Absorbs oven heat and transfers it evenly.Do not clean the stone with...
  • Recommended for up to 500 degrees in a standard home oven

The 16” Honey-Can-Do Pizza Stone lists as one of Amazon’s Choice products that weigh 7.28 pounds. It’s a cordierite-made model, meaning that it heats up well in the oven and distributes heat evenly while baking your pizza.

Moreover, the 16” Honey-Can-Do Pizza Stone its manufacturing includes a mix of lead-free clays. Such uniform crafting makes it more durable and less prone to cracking.

To make restaurant-like pizzas, you must first heat the stone separately before baking at 5000 oven heat. Both the soggy-free midsection and the wide 16″ baking surface allow you to keep your bake symmetrical and pizza toppings very tidy.

Furthermore, the 16” Honey-Can-Do Pizza Stone has 4.5-stars from more than 627 global ratings and verified users.

Apart from generally rinsing and air drying your purchase, you’ll also be required to season the stone periodically for better results. Just remember not to use soap while cleaning it.

Pros

  • Wide and round for symmetrical bakes
  • Distributes heat evenly
  • Easy to maintain
  • Not prone to cracking

Cons

  • Contain toxic substance known to the state of California

Buy on Amazon

3. The Hans Grill Baking Pizza Stone Set

Hans Grill Baking Pizza Stone
  • ULTIMATE PIZZA STONE SET WITH FREE PEEL - Our pizza stone and wooden...
  • ITALIAN PIZZA IN OVEN or BBQ - Soggy bottoms are a thing of the past!...
  • OVEN, BBQ, GRILL OR HOB – These Pizza stones are made to be used...
  • PERFECT THICKNESS FOR OPTIMAL RESULTS - After months of testing, Hans...

The Hans Grill Baking Pizza Stone Set is a stoneware-made pizza stone that measures 14.96 x 11.81 x 0.59 inches and has a rectangle shape. As Amazon’s Choice product, the Hans Grill Baking Pizza Stone will undoubtedly unleash the master pizza-making skills within you.

Its package usually comprises a rectangular pizza baking stone and a wooden peeling board. A more common combination meant to provide you with a versatile cooking arsenal for increased kitchen efficiency.

In terms of safety, the Hans Grill Baking Pizza Stone Set features a pair of long wooden handles to help prevent any accidental burns while baking.

Apart from just making pizza, the wide rectangular pizza stone can also bake and cook a large variety of meals such as loaves of bread, pies, and rolls. The good thing is that you won’t have to deal with soggy-centers as well as burnt pizza edges anymore.

Furthermore, its premium making allows it to cook from ovens, charcoal stoves, BBQ grills, gas, and the traditional wood fire oven.

Pros

  • Versatile in nature
  • Can cook a variety of other foods
  • Great safety features
  • Supports a variety of cooking options

Cons

  • Prone to breaking

Buy on Amazon

4. Unicook 12 Inch Round Pizza Stone

Unicook 12 Inch Round Pizza Stone
  • Made of all natural Cordierite stone, sintered in 2100°F kiln for...
  • Full of invisible micro-pores which absorb and eliminate excess...
  • Heat resistant up to 1,450°F (787°C). Great for cooking fresh or...
  • 12 inch Pizza Stone: Family-size Baking Stone, measures 12" in...

The Unicook 12 Inch Round Pizza Stone is an Amazon Choice product, cordierite-made, and measures 12.01 x 12.01 x 0.63 inches in dimensions. Initial sintering in extremely hot kilns forms a critical manufacturing process, especially for curing and durability purposes.

Cordierite compounds primarily enhances the model’s ability to conduct heat faster, heat evenly, and retain the heat for slow cooking. It additionally improves its overall resistance to thermal shock.

The Unicook 12 Inch Round Pizza Stone is highly absorbent due to its numerous micro-pores. These small openings also ward off the usual sogginess of metal pans. Such features considerably contribute to the creation of crispy pizza crusts.

With the ability to heat up to 787°C, the Unicook brand is perfect for cooking frozen and fresh pizza using the usual kitchen oven or outdoor grill. Apart from pizza, you can alternatively bake cookies and biscuits with it for all your loved ones.

It’s family-sized and also comes with a free plastic scraper for scraping off pizza residues once it has cooled. You can alternatively use the scrapper to cut your dough during the baking process.

To care for your purchase, all you need to do is to oven-dry the stone after cleaning it before storing it in a dry place.

Pros

  • Easy to maintain
  • Highly absorbent
  • High thermal shock resistance
  • Free multi-use scrapper

Cons

  • Odor problems

Buy on Amazon

5. Heritage Pizza Stone

Sale
Heritage Pizza Stone
  • -Fast Food: These pizza stones for oven use pre-heat twice as fast as...
  • -Minimise Mess: Our superior baking stone is grease and burn...
  • -Durable: Our pizza stone for oven use is cast from black ceramic and...
  • -The Perfect Slice: Our pizza stone for oven and BBQ cooking comes...

The Heritage Pizza Stone is 3.15-pound cookware that measures 15.79 x 15.79 x 2.48 inches and is round in shape. It’s ceramic-made and can heat up twice as fast compared to other brands available in the market.

Generally, Heritage Pizza Stone features a tapered edge design, meaning that you can easily use your purchase for serving as well.

Its unique non-stick glaze coating prevents your pizza from sticking to the stone or get stains from grease and burnt crust. The glaze additionally simplifies maintenance since you’ll only need to sponge the model with warm water and mild detergent.

Heritage pizza grilling stones are usually very durable and can easily sustain ultra-high temperatures.

Luckily, the Heritage Pizza Stone does not smoke when heated and additionally comes with a wheel cutter for the perfect pizza slice.

One last tip, remember to set your oven at room temperature first (when using it) before bringing it to the desired cooking temperature. Directly immersing it in a hot fireplace might cause cracks and breakages.

Pros

  • Easy to clean
  • Long-lasting
  • Features a protective glaze
  • Perfect giftware

Cons

  • Easily cracks

Buy on Amazon

6. 15” Ceramic JulyPanny Pizza Stone

Sale
Ceramic JulyPanny Pizza Stone
  • O [ Made of All Natural ] Our pizza stones are made of all-natural...
  • O [ Make Multiple Foods ] This round pizza stone is not only for...
  • O [ Exquisite Pizza Size ] Measures 15" by 0.43". Suitable thickness,...
  • O [ Heating Balance Design ] It is different with metal pans which...

The 15” Ceramic JulyPanny Pizza Stone contains carefully formulated cordierite. A typical cordierite-ceramic combination is widely known for high thermal resistance, meaning that the JulyPanny Pizza Stone can endure very high baking temperatures.

The wide 15″ by 0.43″ surface generally gives it the perfect thickness for preheating and cooking exquisitely large pizzas enough for your whole family. Its support for grills, gas stoves, and ovens makes it even more suitable for large family gatherings.

Besides making delicious round pizzas with it, the 15” Ceramic JulyPanny Pizza Stone can also bake bread, BBQ steak, and roast chicken.

Well, all its praise as the most helpful baking assistant isn’t for nothing. It’s a multipurpose option with highly absorbent features, meaning that you can easily use it to prepare restaurant-quality crispy pastries for dinner every pizza night.

To avoid food intoxication, remember to avoid using soaps and detergents while washing the stone. To clean it, plainly rinse and store it in a dry place. To prevent staining, consider wrapping the surface in tinfoil before baking.

Pros

  • Cooks multiple foods
  • Supports multiple cooking stoves
  • Rinse to clean
  • Exquisitely large for family-size pizzas

Cons

  • Not dishwasher ready

Buy on Amazon

7. The 15” Hans Grill Baking Pizza Stone

Sale
Hans Grill Baking Pizza Stone
  • ULTIMATE PIZZA STONE SET WITH FREE PEEL - Our pizza stone and wooden...
  • PERFECT THICKNESS FOR OPTIMAL RESULTS - After months of testing, Hans...
  • OVEN, BBQ, GRILL OR HOB – These Pizza stones are made to be used...
  • ITALIAN PIZZA IN OVEN or BBQ - Soggy bottoms are a thing of the past!...

The 15” Hans Grill Baking Pizza Stone is a circular-shaped and stone-made pick. Ranked as an Amazon Choice product in the category of pizza grilling stones by Hans Grills, the 15” Hans Grill Baking Pizza Stone will help impress your family with your “silent” pizza master chef skills.

Its package widely presents an unrivaled pizza baking combo that comprises a highly durable pizza baking stone and a wooden board for peeling your pizza.

Luckily, the peeling board features a long wooden handle to help keep you safe while baking. Phew! At least you won’t have to deal with accidental burns ever again.

The 15” Hans Grill Baking Pizza Stone is one of the best kitchen arsenals for any kitchen. Its multi-use capabilities allow it to bake, cook, grill, and serve your delicious pastry.

Don’t just restrict yourself to making crispy pizzas only. You can additionally bake bread, pies, and rolls with it. Its other exciting features include no soggy midsections and the ability to be used in ovens, directly on BBQ grills, gas, charcoal stoves, etc.

Pros

  • Wooden safety handle
  • No soggy center
  • Large cooking surface
  • Free peeling board for your pizzas

Cons

  • Quality concerns

Buy on Amazon

8. AUGOSTA Pizza Stone for Oven and Grill

Sale
AUGOSTA Pizza Stone
  • Size: The pizza stone measures 15" X 12" X 0.6", Golden...
  • Material: Made of 100% all-natural FDA-safe Cordierite stone, it is no...
  • Multipurpose: Besides baking the fresh or frozen pizzas, this pizza...
  • Clean: Scrape off any excess food with a spatula before clean. When...

The AUGOSTA Pizza Stone for Oven and Grill is an Amazon Choice pizza grilling stone made by the company called AUGOSTA. It features a golden thickness of 15mm, measures 15″ X 12″ X 0.6″, and weighs close to 6.7 pounds.

The main compounds used to make it include 100% natural cordierite, and it’s FDA-approved to be safe for use. The stone can safely support extreme temperatures of up to 1112°F, evenly distributes throughout the surface, making it ideal for slow cooking.

Also, the AUGOSTA Pizza Stone for Oven and Grill supports multiple culinary explorations, and you can easily bake different types of bread, stuffed calzone, and biscuits with it. Otherwise, the model is more suitable for making both fresh and frozen pizzas.

Another key feature includes a free wooden pizza peeling paddle that comes with a long wooden handle to keep you safe from burning yourself while cooking.

To clean it, first wait for the stone to cool down, scrape off any food residues, run warm water over it, and gently scrub using a brush. Generally, avoid using soap or washing detergents while cleaning to prevent getting a soapy aftertaste in your future pizza.

Pros

  • Free wooden pizza peeling paddle
  • Wide enough for family-sized pizza
  • Easy to maintain
  • Retains heat well

Cons

  • Size inconsistencies

Buy on Amazon

9. 12” GEEBOBO Pizza Stone for Oven and Grill

Sale
GEEBOBO Pizza Stone
  • Come With a free bamboo pizza peel board. This12 inch pizza stone for...
  • Multipurpose: Beasides baking fresh or frozen pizzas,this pizza stone...
  • How to Clean: When the pizza stone has completely cooled off, Scrape...
  • Sizes: 12 inch pizza stone measures 12"x12"x0.35", the pizza peel...

As one of Amazon’s Choice pizza grilling stones by GEEBOBO, the 12” GEEBOBO Pizza Stone for Oven and Grill contains 100% natural cordierite compounds.

The model is FDA-safe, and it generally doesn’t emit any smell when heated.

Cordierite compound allows it to withstand very high temperatures of up to 800°C making it ideal for optimal pizza making. It further enables even distribution of heat, facilitates high heat retention, and increases overall thermal shock abilities.

Furthermore, it contains numerous tiny micro-pores that effectively absorb moisture, making it easy to make crispy and crunchy pizzas. Apart from pizza, you can also use the GEEBOBO pizza grilling stone for all your other baking needs at home.

One advantageous feature is that the 12” GEEBOBO Pizza Stone for Oven and Grill has a 0.35″ thickness that fastens heating relative to most of its competitors.

Like many other pizza stone options, GEEBOBO Pizza Stones are always easy to clean so long as you don’t use soap and other detergents. Just wait for it to cool down, scrape off excess crusts, and scrub with a brush in warm running water.

Pros

  • Free bamboo pizza peeling paddle
  • Supports up to 800°C
  • Made of 100% natural FDA-safe material
  • Preheats very fast

Cons

  • Odor issues

Buy on Amazon

10. NeoCasa Black Cordierite Ceramic Coated Pizza Stone Pan Set

NeoCasa Black Cordierite Ceramic Coated
  • 🍕 CRISPY BRICK OVEN TASTE: Get that perfect crispy crust and...
  • 🍕 STAINLESS & NON-STICK: Our pre-glazed 15" X 12" ceramic cooking...
  • 🍕 VERSATILE: Our pizza stone set can be also be used for baking...
  • 🍕 COMPLETE SET TO BE YOUR OWN ITALIAN CHEF: The included pizza peel...

The NeoCasa Black Cordierite Ceramic Coated Pizza Stone Pan Set is a rectangular Amazon Choice product for heritage pizza stones. Its making includes cordierite compounds and a ceramic coat for a stainless finish.

A pre-glazed finish is known to result in non-stick surfaces. NeoCasa takes things a notch higher by pre-treating the model to ensure that you get crispy pizzas with brick-oven taste right out of the box.

It’s highly versatile, and you can easily prepare different kinds of pastries and BBQ your meat with it. Interestingly, you can use it on different types of grills, ovens, and gas for cooking.

The NeoCasa Black Cordierite Ceramic Coated Pizza Stone Set is a quick starter package that additionally comes with a bamboo-made pizza peeling board and a pizza blade for slicing your masterpiece.

Nevertheless, the included pizza-making eBook contains more than 30 different pizza recipes meant to enhance your pizza-making skills and wow your family and colleagues.

Pros

  • Pizza eBook included
  • Free pizza paddle
  • Free pizza cutting blade
  • Stainless finish

Cons

  • Breaks easily

Buy on Amazon

Buying Guide: What to Consider When Choosing The Best Pizza Stone

Here are the most important considerations to keep in mind when searching for the best pizza stone for your kitchen.

Best Pizza Stone

a) Size and Shape

While it’s tempting to go for the largest pizza stone in the market, you must remember to only go for the one that will fit your cooking setup. No matter what you generally intend to use for cooking, consider measuring your oven first before buying.

Use the measurements as a guide in identifying the best pizza stone that will perfectly fit your oven, stove, BBQ grill, or even microwave.

b) Thickness

Depending on what you generally use for cooking, the thickness always dictates how fast a pizza stone conducts heat. For those using conventional kitchen ovens, thinner options might be best for your setup because they’ll heat up much quicker.

On the other hand, thicker stones are best left for proper pizza ovens as they often heat up much faster and become extremely hot than the home oven.

c) Rough or Smooth

Many beginners often have a hard time between these two options. While many experts recommend going for stones with rough surfaces, you should consider getting the smooth one first.

Given that pizza dough is usually sticky, smooth surfaces often reduce its adhesion levels and prevent creating a mess. Additionally, you might want to consider spreading the semolina flour on the surface first before baking.

Semolina here functions as a dry lubricant and prevents burning and sticking.

Wrapping It Up

Finding the perfect pizza stone generally improves the quality of your pastries despite your preferred cooking setup, and it’s one of the most worthwhile investments you might ever make.

Getting one generally means that you can now enjoy healthier, tastier, fresher, and crustier pizzas every pizza night.

Since identifying the best pizza stone for you might be challenging due to the sheer number of options to choose from, we hope that the above review and buying guide will help you find the perfect pizza stone for you and your family.

References

https://www.epicurious.com/expert-advice/the-best-pizza-stones-and-baking-stones-of-2020-article

 

Leave a Comment