10 Best Ice Cream Scoop America’s Test Kitchen of 2021

Summer is coming, and with it, the greatest season for indulging in ice cream. There’s nothing more refreshing than fresh ice cream served up with the best ice cream scoop to stave off the sweltering heat.

That’s why it’s important to avoid the frustration of an ice cream scoop that brings nothing but frustration when trying to scoop out that perfect scoop.

Top 5 Best Ice Cream Scoop America’s Test Kitchen: Editor’s Pick

Below we put together a collection of what we felt were the best ice cream scoops and close by revealing our personal favorite.

The 10 Best Ice Cream Scoop America’s Test Kitchen Reviews:

1. Comfortable Ice Cream Scoop From Spring Chef

Comfortable Ice Cream Scoop
  • THE LAST ICE CREAM SCOOP YOU'LL NEED - Genuine heavy duty tool that is...
  • CREATE PERFECT SPHERES OF ICE CREAM - cuts through smoothly and...
  • INNOVATIVE DESIGN SAVES YOU TIME AND ENERGY - Unique shape that is the...
  • PLOWS THROUGH ICE CREAM LIKE IT'S BUTTER - Glides smoothly and easily...

Trying to get that perfect scoop of ice cream out of the container can be a real bear with a standard scoop, but this offering from Spring Chef overcomes all that. With a wide flat scoop and a rubberized handle that provides both a solid grip and protection from the bare cold metal, this tool takes the chore out of scooping ice cream.

.The shape of the scoop means that this is more than just a scoop for ice cream; it can be put to numerous other uses in the kitchen, like removing seeds from melons or getting the arils out of a pomegranate. When you dip into your next box of ice cream using this scoop, you’ll be able to create the perfect spheres that everyone loves.

Even better, you won’t have to worry about wasting any of the delicious dairy treats, thanks to the flat edge design that makes scraping out the last bit a breeze. We were truly impressed with all the features this scoop delivered, with the only weak point being the lack of a trigger to push the ice cream out of the scoop.

Pros

  • Comfort grip handle that protects from cold and gives grip
  • Sturdy metal design that will last a lifetime
  • Flat shape of the scoop means no ice cream is left behind

Cons

  • No trigger mechanism to release the ice cream from the scoop

Buy on Amazon

2. Classic Large Ice Cream Scoop In Stainless Steel From Solula

Sale
Classic Large Ice Cream Scoop
  • SIZE - Capacity: 2.53 tablespoon / 38ml / 1.28 fl oz. Bowl diameter: 1...
  • SAVE YOUR TIME -- A simple squeeze releases cookie dough, makes...
  • SAFE FOR FOOD - Made of 18/8 stainless steel, premium food-grade...
  • EASY TO USE - Heavy-duty spring action releases food by sliding band...

Professional ice cream scoopers know that not every sphere of ice cream easily slides free of the scoop when serving. They also know that relying on a flimsy trigger mechanism is a sure-fire way to slow down their workflow and create disappointed customers.

The Solula Ice Cream Scoop addresses these issues with a comfortable and intuitive design that makes creating the perfect scoop and delivering it a breeze. The stainless steel design provides a quality of construction that ensures that it’s going to stand the test of time.

It’s also easy to clean and fits perfectly in any kitchen drawer. Like any good kitchen utensil, this scoop isn’t just a single-purpose tool. It’s perfect for scooping melon balls, and measuring out cookie dough without the mess, just for a start.

The overall design of this is simple but done in a way that makes maximum use of the user’s hand strength without soreness. Even better, it’s an absolute breeze to clean! You can just toss it in your dishwasher and call it a day.

Pros

  • Quick and easy scoop release mechanism
  • Stainless steel design is durable and easy to clean
  • Versatile design for multiple uses

Cons

  • Small scoop size

Buy on Amazon

3. Large Gorilla Group Ice Cream Scoop By Gorilla Scoop

Sale
Large Gorilla Group Ice Cream Scoop
  • Won't Bend or Break: never struggle with scooping stubborn, rock solid...
  • Comfortable And Easy to Use: easy to grip and slip resistant handle...
  • Perfect Scoops: the shape of the scooper gives off perfect curls,...
  • Gets The Most Ice Cream: the smart design also includes flat edges on...

This scoop measures in at an impressive 7.5″ long and sports a generous 2″ wide scoop along with a comfortable silicone grip handle that protects your hands from the cold. This ensures that you’re able to take advantage of the durability of the zinc-alloy material without losing your grip, even when scooping the hardest ice cream.

This alloy gives the scoop its resilience that ensures it will last a lifetime and won’t bend when scooping ice cream, cleaning out pumpkins, lifting meatballs out of sauce, and any of a hundred other uses.

While the primary function of this scoop is scooping food items like ice cream, it also comes with a convenient hook on the handle. This hook allows the user to lift stubborn container lids, such as can be found with hard frozen ice cream containers.

No matter what you use it for, you won’t have to worry about cleaning it; you just need to place it in the dishwasher and let the machine do its work. Its durable design means it will be with you for years to come.

Pros

  • Convenient lid opening design
  • Silicone ensures a no-slip grip and freedom from cold
  • Zinc-Alloy material is durable and long-lasting

Cons

  • Wide design can make it difficult to use on smaller containers

Buy on Amazon

4. Stainless Steel Spade Ice Cream Scoop From BALCI

Stainless Steel Spade Ice Cream Scoop
  • QUALITY WITH NO COMPROMISE - SOLID STAINLESS STEEL - RISK FREE...
  • EFFORTLESSLY CUT THROUGH HARD FROZEN SOLID ICE CREAM! Other ice cream...
  • DISHWASHER SAFE and 100% BPA FREE! They say you cant have your cake...
  • INDESTRUCTIBLE - SOLID STAINLESS STEEL ICE-CREAM SCOOP - This Scoop is...

A complete and thought-out design is a thing of beauty in any tool, and ice cream scoops are no exception. This ice cream scoop is an example of what happens to a simple kitchen utensil when someone takes the time to think out every aspect of its design.

Stainless steel is a strong and lasting material that can survive in your kitchen for generations, and its design will make it a favorite go-to for your scooping needs. Combine it with the silicone cover on the handle and a stainless steel core for the handle that makes it strong and able to withstand the rigors of even the toughest ice cream.

The spade design makes digging into a fresh container of ice cream as easy as scooping out the contents of a pumpkin or balling a melon. Like the other scoops on this list, this one is easy to clean with a simple dishwasher cycle.

Unlike the others, this one comes with a lifetime guarantee and is BPA-free! It’s sure to find a place in your celebrations and food prep for years to come.

Pros

  • BPA free silicone handle
  • Full stainless steel core design
  • Narrow scoop good for multiple container types

Cons

  • Design can make it hard to clean the sides of ice cream containers

Buy on Amazon

5. Ergonomic Ice Cream Scoop By Midnight Scoop

Sale
Ergonomic Ice Cream Scoop
  • You Have Been Scooping Ice Cream Wrong - Instead of prying at hard ice...
  • Dig Through Hard Ice Cream with Ease - The curved handle is...
  • Dishwasher Safe - Made with solid stainless steel for quick and easy...
  • Featured as one of Oprah's Favorite Things - If Oprah loves it, you...

Creating the perfect ice cream scoop is equal parts art and science, and this design from Midnight Scoop does so perfectly. The handle is sleek, graceful, and ribbed to ensure a sturdy grip, while the fluted design of the bowl ensures it gets a perfect bite into your ice cream.

The subtle curve of the handle is more than just an aesthetic choice; it actually helps provide leverage while digging even the hardest ice cream. More than that, it also provides an extra bit of weight right where you need it to ease the effort required and reduce weariness.

The stainless steel design of this scoop ensures that it’s easy to clean, resistant to corrosion, and durable enough to last several lifetimes. Even if you actually manage to break it, it comes with a lifetime guarantee that ensures you’ll never have to be concerned about replacing it.

Its design has another unexpected aspect as well. It happens to be perfect for those suffering from conditions like arthritis and carpal tunnel, as it puts less pressure on the hands and wrist.

Pros

  • Solid stainless steel design
  • Reduces strain on hands and wrist
  • Lifetime guaranteed

 Cons

  • Bare stainless steel transmits cold from ice cream

Buy on Amazon

6. 3 Piece Ice Cream Scoop Set From Chee Mong

3 Piece Ice Cream Scoop Set
  • 3 SIZE COOKIE SCOOPS - Ice cream scoop set, Small scoop (ball...
  • THREE DIFFERENT SIZE, MEET DIFFERENT NEEDS - Use this cookie scoop to...
  • ICE CREAM SCOOPS WITH ERGONOMIC TRIGGER, PP HANDLE, EASY TO USE - The...
  • PREMIUM 18/8 STAINLESS - Polishing stainless cookie scoop have...

Not all ice cream lovers have the same size appetites, so why should you rely on a single-size scoop? This offering from Chee Mong provides three different size scoops with color-coded handles equipped with simple thumb-press triggers to drop the scoop out of the bowl.

The three sizes include a 1-1/2T size, 2-1/2T size, and a 5-1/4T size for those jumbo-sized scoops. This also means you can create variant sizes of melon and fruit balls to add visual interest to your offerings for guests.

Imagine three large scoops of ice cream sprinkled with 1-1/2T size watermelon balls! Another great aspect of these scoops is how easy they are to clean.

Both the plastic handles and the stainless steel scoops are able to be easily cleaned or rinsed and can even go into your dishwasher without concern. They have the added bonus of being great for cookie dough and pancake batter, allowing you to easily make multiple sizes.

Pros

  • Easily cleanable design
  • Contains multiple scoop sizes
  • Easy to use thumb triggers

Cons

  • Not suitable for use with hard ice-creams or sub-zero ice cream.

Buy on Amazon

7. Aqua Ice Cream Scoop by Kitchen-Aid

Aqua Ice Cream Scoop
  • Cast zinc head: The scoop's sharp, cast zinc head makes scooping hard...
  • Ergonomic Handle for Comfort: The scoop features an ergonomic handle...
  • Perfect size for scooping: the KitchenAid ice cream scoop measures 8....
  • Dishwasher safe: this ice cream scoop is dishwasher safe, making clean...

As one of the most trusted names in kitchen wares, it should come as no surprise that a Kitchen-Aid ice cream scoop made it onto our list. This scoop is made from beautiful and reliable cast zinc, creating a seamless tool for scooping out your favorite ice cream.

The handle is coated in ABS, a special form of plastic that exhibits thermoplasticity. What does this mean for your scoop? It means you’ll never experience the discomfort of cold metal when scooping your ice cream.

At just over eight inches long, this ice cream scoop will fit perfectly in the palm of your hand for serious scooping. As a special nod to the incredible company that produces this quality product, there’s a 1919 stamp on the stainless steel endcap.

This is the date that Kitchen-Aid first started bringing up quality appliances and kitchenware. As a trusted name, it’s no surprise that they offer a lifetime warranty on their products, so this scoop is going to be with you for a lifetime.

Pros

  • Elegant design by a trusted company
  • Comfortable ABS handle protects from cold
  • Lifetime warranty makes it the last scoop you’ll need

Cons

  • Not a stainless steel construction

Buy on Amazon

8. Ice Cream Scoop With Heavy Duty Handle And Soft Grip From Spring Chef

Ice Cream Scoop With Heavy Duty Handle
  • The Last Ice Cream Scoop You'll Need - 100% Grade 304 Stainless Steel...
  • Create Perfect Spheres of Ice Cream - cuts through smoothly and...
  • Innovative Design Saves You Time And Energy - Unique shape that is the...
  • Plows Through Ice Cream Like It's Butter - Glides smoothly and easily...

The best ice cream scoop is for those with a serious love of that rich dairy treat and is durable enough to last a lifetime even with constant use. The scoop itself is comprised of flawless stainless steel and curved to a perfect shape for creating a great ice cream sphere.

Those who have hands sensitive to the cold don’t need to worry as the silicone handle ensures protection against the cold metal of the scoop itself. The coating doesn’t hide any surprises either; the metal core of the scoop goes all the way down the handle for a solid grip.

For such a simple device, it’s packed with design elements that ensure it saves time and effort when scooping ice cream. Consider the rounded curve of the scoop that makes forming spheres of ice cream a breeze.

Also makes it simple to scrape out the last vestiges of your ice cream container. Dishwasher safe and supported by a lifetime guarantee, this ice cream scoop is sure to become a family favorite for generations.

Pros

  • Innovative design creates ease of use
  • Lifetime warranty makes a secure investment
  • Scoop design for perfect large scoops

Cons

  • No trigger for releasing the scoop

Buy on Amazon

9. Pretty In Pink 2 Oz Ice Cream Scoop From BASTEK

Pretty In Pink 2 Oz Ice Cream Scoop
  • PERFECT USE:The spoon head is made of 304 stainless steel and is...
  • PERSONALIZED STYLING: Pink icecream scooper with trigger,comfortable...
  • PERFECT SIZE:Large size 2 ounce cookie spade 8.26 inches long, spoon...
  • WIDE RANGE OF USES:Ice cream scoop with release,you can easily grab...

This ice cream scoop looks like a high-tech blast from the 1950’s Better Home and Gardens edition. Something about the straightforward design and dusty pastel color of the handle serves as a reminder of family dinners followed by that coveted scoop of ice cream afterward.

Like any good kitchen tool, this device serves as more than just a simple ice cream scoop; it can ball fruit, measure out pancake and biscuit batter, and so much more.

Made from solid stainless steel, you’ll know that this piece can be a reliable addition to your utensil drawer and will be serving your family for generations to come.

The stainless steel design of this utensil ensures that the trigger never bends or twists and that you’ll be able to easily push the scoop out of the bowl with a minimum of pressure. Like all the stainless steel offerings on this list, it’s completely dishwasher safe, so it’s convenient and easy to clean.

Pros

  • Stylish 1950’s Aesthetic
  • Convenient thumb-operated scraper
  • Easy to clean

Cons

  • Pink color not perfect for every decorating scheme

Buy on Amazon

10. Happyware Aluminum Ice Cream Scoop With Easy Grip Handle

Sale
Happyware Aluminum Ice Cream Scoop
  • THE BEST-- AND LAST—ICE CREAM SCOOP YOU'LL NEED! - Made with...
  • CUT THROUGH ICE CREAM LIKE BUTTER! - The solid aluminum construction...
  • 100% MADE IN THE USA! – This is not made in CHINA! From the design...
  • DISHWASHER SAFE! - Coated and finished to withstand any dishwashing...

This piece stands out as the only utensil on this list that isn’t made out of stainless steel or zinc. Unlike the pieces above that focus on protecting your hand from the cold of the ice cream, this one takes another approach.

Users of this ice cream scoop will find that heat from their hand is conducted through the aluminum to make it cut through your dairy treat like butter.

Those who are being conscious of where the item is constructed will be glad to know this is a 100% USA-made product, guaranteeing quality. Aluminum is a durable product that will last as long as your family, and the non-stick coating ensures that ice cream slides right off the bowl.

Those concerned about quality will be happy to know that the aluminum scoop is completely solid, with no air spaces to skimp on materials. As with all the options found on this list, it’s easy to clean in your dishwasher.

Pros

  • American Construction
  • Solid aluminum design conducts heat
  • Dishwasher safe for easy cleaning

Cons

  • Lacks a scraper to release ice cream

Buy on Amazon

Buying Guide: What to Consider When Select Ice Cream Scoop

Ice Cream Scoop

In order to determine which of the above scoops is going to suit your needs, it’s important to understand the various options that are available with a scoop and how they’ll affect its performance.

Below are a series of things that were considered in selecting items for this list and picking our favorite:

  • Material – Stainless steel is definitely the preferred, followed by aluminum construction. Zinc is known for becoming brittle when exposed to cold.
  • Handle – A coated handle gives the benefit of protecting your hand from the cold but prevents your body heat from aiding scooping.
  • Shape – The shape of the scoop has a direct effect on how easy it is to use and how easy it is to get that perfect shape. Some shapes come with benefits lacking in others.
  • Scraper – A scraper is an important part of an ice cream scoop for many, as it helps release the ice cream from the bowl without touching it.

Each of these played a role in our decision-making process and helped us reach our final verdict.

Final Verdict

The offering from Midnight Scoop won out with us in the end as the best ice cream scoop. There’s just something about its sleek design and commitment to function that made it stand out for us.

The stainless steel construction means you’ll never buy another scoop, while the design ensures ease of use. While it lacks a scraper or handle coating, we find that the bulk of the handle makes the latter unnecessary, and the ice cream still slips seamlessly off the scoop.

Leave a Comment