10 Best Dutch Ovens America’s Test Kitchen of 2021

Dutch ovens are some of the most indispensable kitchenware for any home. These deep, lidded, cast-iron-made pots are known to bring lots of flexibility to any kitchen.

Top 5 Best Dutch Ovens America’s Test Kitchen: Editor’s Pick

Given their ability to effectively hold huge amounts of heat, getting a Dutch oven is a practical solution to almost any of your cooking needs. Some of the things that they are widely known for include simmering stew, baking bread, tenderizing vegetables, and braising your meat.

Now that you are interested in getting one for your household, here is a quick buying guide with the 10 best Dutch ovens to buy this year.

The 10 Best Dutch Ovens America’s Test Kitchen Review:

1. The 7 Quart Lodge Pre-Seasoned Dutch Oven

Sale
Lodge Pre-Seasoned Dutch Oven
  • one lodge pre-seasoned 7 quart cast iron dutch oven
  • loop handles for secure control
  • cast iron cover features self-basting tips
  • unparalleled heat retention and even heating

The 7 Quart Lodge Pre-Seasoned Dutch oven is a cast iron-made cookware that comes with loop handles to give you more control while cooking and a fitting cast iron lid for self-basting. This classic kitchenware is round in shape and features unparalleled heat retention.

Its ability to heat evenly coupled with the fact that it comes pre-seasoned and ready-to-cook makes it the ideal tool for nearly all of your cooking needs. You can use it to bake, sauté, sear, simmer, braise, fry, and even roast.

No matter how often you use your 7 Quart Lodge Pre-Seasoned Dutch oven, its cast-iron material makes it brutally tough and long-lasting.

The best thing about this model is that you can cook with it from almost anywhere, meaning that you can use it on the stove, in the oven, on your grill, and over a campfire. The only place you can’t use it is in the microwave.

For maintenance purposes, simply wash it with soap and water, dry it with a towel, apply a light layer of cooking oil on it, and store it in a dry place.

Pros

  • Easy to maintain
  • Very durable
  • Pre-seasoned and ready-to-cook
  • Loop handles for secure control

Cons

  • Can’t be used in the microwave

Buy on Amazon

2. 6 Quart Lodge Enameled Cast Iron Dutch Oven

Lodge Enameled Cast Iron
  • One Lodge 6 Quart Red Enameled Cast Iron Dutch Oven
  • Features a stainless steel knob and loop handles for great control
  • Smooth glass surface won't react to ingredients
  • Unparalleled heat retention and even heating

The 6 Quart Lodge Enameled Cast Iron Dutch oven comes with a 5.6-liter capacity and lists as one of Amazon’s Choice products for the Dutch oven by Lodge.

It is round in shape and features loop handles and a stainless knob for your security and control around the kitchen. Like many other cast-iron Dutch ovens made by Lodge, the 6 Quart Lodge Enameled Cast Iron Dutch oven heats evenly and retains heat perfectly.

You can easily heat it to 5000F in the oven to broil, roast, braise, or bake. Alternatively, simply use it from the top of your cooking stove if you want to simmer your stew, sauté, or fry.

The rare blend of both cast iron and the porcelain enamel makes the 6 Quart Lodge Enameled Cast Iron Dutch oven uniquely ideal for margination and refrigeration purposes. Its brilliant exterior gloss additionally makes it perfect for serving.

Remember to avoid using metallic pads and citrus-based detergents while washing to maintain its original gloss.

Pros

  • Great for a variety of cooking needs
  • Perfect for serving
  • It’s dishwasher ready
  • Has more security and control features

Cons

  • Less durable

Buy on Amazon

3. 7-Quart Crock-Pot Artisan Oval Enameled Cast Iron Dutch Oven

Sale
Crock-Pot Artisan Oval
  • Crock Pot Artisan Oval Enameled Cast Iron Dutch Oven, 7-Quart, Teal...
  • Hand wash recommended
  • Perfect for slow-cooking, simmering, braising, baking and more
  • Durable cast iron construction retains and distributes heat evenly

The 7-Quart Crock-Pot Artisan Oval Enameled Cast Iron Dutch oven ranks as Amazon’s Choice in the category of Dutch ovens by Crock-Pot. It’s a one-pot wonder, and you can easily cook your favorite meal straight from your oven/stove to the table.

This Dutch oven comes with a convenient design that makes it both multifunctional and long-lasting. Despite its enameled cast iron finish, this Dutch oven all kinds of stovetops.

The pot has great heat retention and distribution capability making it the ideal choice for slow cooking. When using it in the oven, remember that it’s only safe for use up to 4500F.

What’s more?

The 7-Quart Crock-Pot Artisan Oval Enameled Cast Iron Dutch Oven comes with a self-basting lid, oversized handles, and features a stainless knob for secure control while cooking.

Lucky for you, this model is available in seven different colors that enhance its enameled finish. Remember to only use either wooden or silicon cooking tools to avoid scratching your pot’s surface.

Pros

  • Easy to maintain
  • Supports a variety of cooking
  • Supports all stovetops
  • Convenient design

Cons

  • The surface can easily get scratched

Buy on Amazon

4. Overmont Camp Dutch Oven

Overmont Camp
  • All-round Dutch Oven. The integral legs on both pot and lid allow the...
  • Well known as a Lifetime Pot. Compared with pots of other materials,...
  • Energy-saving and therefor good for the environment. Heat is evenly...
  • Considering the considerable weight of cast iron, Overmont equips a...

The Overmont Camp Dutch Oven is well known for its value proposition. It is an all-around Dutch oven that uniquely comes with integral legs for steady support and cooking over a campfire. Its lid is another wonder as it also works as a skillet casserole for frying.

Unlike several modern designs, the Overmont Camp Dutch Oven make doesn’t include coating with toxic substances. Instead, it is one of the safest non-stick cookware you can get.

This model is made of superior quality cast iron material for durability and good heat retention. This material also ensures that heat is distributed evenly and is held well for searing, deep-frying, or baking purposes.

Furthermore, other beneficial features include durable handles, a lid lifter, and great insulation that makes it much easier to use while camping. Once done, give it a quick hand wash, wipe it dry, rub a light layer of oil while it’s still warm, and hang it in a dry place.

Pros

  • Great for outdoor enthusiasts
  • Highly durable
  • Superb heat distribution and retention
  • Safest non-stick cookware

Cons

  • Not designed for microwaves

Buy on Amazon

5. Non-Stick Heavy-Duty Cast Iron Dutch Oven w/Enamel Coating

Non-Stick Heavy-Duty Cast Iron
  • LARGE 6-QUART CAPACITY: Feed large groups at weddings, family...
  • VERSATILE USAGE: Usable on gas, electric, ceramic, and induction...
  • HIGH TEMPERATURE RESISTANCE: Safe to heat up to 480 degrees...
  • HIGH-QUALITY DESIGN: Made of thick, heavy-duty cast iron with a glossy...

The 6-quart Ceramic Cast Iron Dutch Oven made by Best Choice Products comes with enough space to cook adequate food for a large family. It’s a versatile kitchen accessory that often supports the use of different stovetops, grills, and ovens.

Its very heavy-duty cast iron material is coated with a glossy and non-sticky enamel finish to complement its high-end design. These materials also offer excellent heat resistance, making the model distribute heat evenly and retain it for a long time.

It supports up to 4800F and is perfect for roasting, baking, cooking, and frying your favorite meals.

Additionally, the 6-quart Ceramic Cast Iron Dutch Oven comes with a set of two side handles that make handling it simpler. Plus, the ceramic-enamel finish makes it easy to clean, and you’ll have to avoid using metal utensils when cooking, or you might ruin the enamel finish.

Pros

  • Large enough to cook food for a big family
  • Great heat conductivity
  • Perfect for all kinds of cooking
  • Highly versatile

Cons

  • Lack of color variety

Buy on Amazon

6. Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet and Double Dutch Oven Set

Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet
  • 2 IN 1 VERSATILITY: Use the 5qt pan and 10 inch skillet separately, or...
  • FACTORY SEASONED: don't waste time and effort seasoning your pans and...
  • SUPERIOR CRAFTSMANSHIP: Our cast iron skillet and Dutch oven combo is...
  • EASY TO CLEAN & MAINTAIN – After every use, cast iron should be hand...

The Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet and Double Dutch Oven Set are a 2 in 1 cooking invention by Cuisinel that features a 5-quart deep pan and a separate 10-inch frying pan that also works as its lid.

This model is particularly popular for its superior craftsmanship that guarantees a lifelong service of high-quality cooking. This workmanship involves the use of high-quality cast iron material and a superior non-stick finish, making it an ideal pick for all kinds of slow cooking.

That said, you can easily use the pot for your signature dish and the skillet top for delicate meals such as frying eggs. One of the best things about this model is that it’s already pre-seasoned, meaning that you won’t have to waste much of your time seasoning the cookware.

The Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet and Double Dutch Oven Set are the easiest to clean and maintain cooking accessories in the market. All you have to do is to wash it by hand and with warm water only.

Pros

  • 2 in 1 design
  • 30-days money-back guarantee
  • Are pre-seasoned and ready-to-use
  • Easy to clean and maintain

Cons

  • Not dishwasher-ready

Buy on Amazon

7. Overmont Double Dutch Oven

Sale
Overmont Double Dutch Oven
  • 5 Quart Seasoned Cast Iron Double Dutch oven. Overmont Cast Iron...
  • PRE-SEASONED COOKWARE. A good seasoning makes all the difference....
  • STURDY, COMFORTABLE HANDLES - We know cookware can get heavy when...
  • VERSATILE, SUPERIOR COOKING - This double cast iron set works...

Listed as Amazon’s Choice product by Overmont, this model features a 5 quart seasoned Dutch oven pot and a 1.6-quart pre-seasoned skillet lid. It’s generally made of cast iron, meaning that this cookware efficiently conducts heat and evenly distributes it for cooking.

Its dome-shaped lid doubles up as a skillet and can be used for roasting and baking that non-knead bread that your family loves so much.

Out of the box, the Overmont Double Dutch Oven is already pre-seasoned with 100% natural cooking oil and is ready-to-use. Apart from saving you spare time from seasoning efforts, this model doesn’t feature a synthetic or chemical coating.

For handling purposes, the Overmont Double Dutch Oven features a pair of sturdy handles coupled with two silicone handle covers. Unlike most non-stick pans, the Overmont Double Dutch Oven can withstand very high temperatures while offering a superior cooking experience.

Both the casserole pot and the skillet lid are highly versatile, and you can cook with them either from your oven or on a stove. It additionally features a separate stand that allows you to use it outdoors on an open campfire.

Pros

  • Highly versatile
  • Superior heat retention capacity
  • 2 in 1 model
  • Easy-release finish

Cons

  • Not self-basting

Buy on Amazon

8. Lodge Color Enameled Cast Iron Dutch Oven

Lodge Color Enameled Cast Iron
  • A flawless pairing of form and function that doesn't quit, the Lodge...
  • WHAT IS PORCELAIN ENAMEL ON CAST IRON? It is actually glass that...
  • MAKE EVERY MEAL A MEMORY. Lodge knows that cooking is about more than...
  • FAMILY-OWNED. Lodge is more than just a business; it’s a family. The...

The Lodge Color Enameled Cast Iron Dutch Oven features a unique blend of cast iron and porcelain enamel in its making. Its premium quality design makes it flawlessly efficient in tolerating very high temperatures and remaining impervious to water and moisture from your food.

This model features a 6-liter capacity, making it great for preparing adequate and memorable meals for your family. Luckily, the cast iron is more durable and will ensure that you continually turn every meal into beautiful memories for a very long time.

Apart from cooking, you can also use this model for margination and refrigeration.

This China-made enameled Dutch oven has excellent heat retention capacities and can heat up to 5000F. Lucky for you, the lid not only tightly fits the pot but also features a stainless steel knob that makes it oven safe.

Despite its overall versatility and support for various cookstoves, the Lodge Color Enameled Cast Iron Dutch Oven isn’t meant for outdoor usage as well as microwaves. Besides being dishwasher-ready, a simple hand wash technique is best for long-term maintenance.

Pros

  • Long-lasting
  • Superior enameled finish
  • 6-liter capacity
  • Dishwasher safe

Cons

  • Not for outdoor use

Buy on Amazon

9. Le Creuset Enameled Cast Iron Signature Sauteuse Oven

Sale
Cast Iron Signature Sauteuse Oven
  • This versatile size is perfect for soups, casseroles and one-pot meals
  • The wide base is great for browning meats on the stovetop before slow...
  • Colorful exterior enamel is shock-resistant to prevent chipping and...
  • Sand-colored interior enamel has a smooth finish that promotes...

The Le Creuset Enameled Cast Iron Signature Sauteuse Oven is a 3.5 quart Amazon’s Choice product for Dutch ovens by Le Creuset. It’s made of cast iron and is good at spreading heat evenly and consistently.

Despite its versatile nature for cooking nearly all one-pot types of dishes, it has a broad base that’s perfect for browning your meat before slow cooking it.

Unlike most enameled models, this brand has a unique but colorful exterior enamel that’s both shock-resistant and crack-proof. On the inside, its sand-colored enameled interior gives it a very smooth finish and helps to prevent stains.

Moreover, the Le Creuset Enameled Cast Iron Signature Sauteuse Oven features a dome-shaped cover that tightly fits into the pot and ensures constant circulation of both heat and moisture while you cook.

Besides being dishwasher safe, we recommend that you read and follow the maintenance instructions that come with the order.

Pros

  • No seasoning needed
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Strong and durable
  • Suitable for stove and oven use

Cons

  • Limited to 3.5 quarts

Buy on Amazon

10. BUYDEEM CP521 3 Quart Dutch Oven

Sale
BUYDEEM CP521 3 Quart
  • Beauty and Functionality in One - Combines with "Cupcake" look design...
  • Makes Food Moist & Juicy - Tight-fitting lid locks in moisture and...
  • Compatible with any cooktop - All stovetops including induction
  • Easy to clean - Non-stick enamel-coating allows for easy cleaning...

The BUYDEEM CP521 3 Quart Dutch Oven is a marvel on its own. It’s famous for its unique design that brings both functionality and beauty to your kitchen.

The cupcake-round design makes it even more appealing and can be used to serve your food once it is ready. Its cast-iron material is efficient enough to heat up fast, distribute the heat evenly, and retain it for a long time.

The good thing is that it’s already compatible with nearly all types of cooktops. This model features a tightly fitting lid that usually locks in moisture and ensures that your favorite dish is moist, juicy, and tasty.

Since Dutch oven maintenance is almost everyone’s concern, the BUYDEEM CP521 3 Quart Dutch Oven is fitted with a non-stick enamel coating for easy cleaning. It generally doesn’t require too much energy and scrubbing to get it clean.

For long-term use, make sure to start cleaning once it has cooled, and don’t use citrus–based detergents. Preferably wash your piece by hand to protect its original gloss.

Pros

  • Cupcake durable design
  • Excellent heat conductivity and retention
  • Tightly fitting lid to lock in food moisture
  • Very easy to clean and maintain

Cons

  • Easily scratched

Buy on Amazon

Buying Guide: What To Consider When Choosing The Dutch Ovens

Best Dutch Ovens

a) Material

Most Dutch ovens are usually cast-iron made – even the enameled ones. However, you might find other varieties made from aluminum, stainless steel, and ceramic compounds.

First, you must note that cast iron has a very high heating capacity and retention capabilities relative to the other materials. The remaining varieties are generally light but generally fail to retain heat for slow cooking.

b) Size

Size often goes hand in hand with the number of people in your household. Dutch oven models are available starting from ¼ quart-size up to 13-quart ovens. Usually, the 5 to 7-quart Dutch ovens are often the best and can be used to cook food for a family of four.

Depending on your family-size, getting one of these popular-sized Dutch ovens will give you enough cooking space for a whole chicken, and you can easily bake your 2-pound bread in it.

However, consider the availability of space for keeping your new purchase. Bulky picks will typically need large storage areas.

c) Shape

By now, it’s apparent that the most beloved Dutch oven shape is round. What you probably don’t know is that there are oval-shaped ones too.

The round models are often the best due to their deep pots and base for distributing heat evenly. The oval-shaped ones are much wider and preferably perfect for oven use only.

However, no matter your preferred shape, you can easily pull off that new recipe you saw online if you pre-heat the Dutch oven first.

d) Heating Capacity

Heating capacity matters a lot during slow cooking, one of the top reasons why people often buy Dutch ovens. Depending on its material, Cast-iron is the most prevalent material used to make Dutch ovens.

Whether enameled or not, cast iron-made Dutch ovens can withstand up to 5000F while the ceramic-made ones have a slightly lower heating capacity. Those made of either cast aluminum or stainless steel usually require moderate temperatures to cook well.

h) Accessories

Those looking to buy a Dutch oven for in-house use only won’t be needing a lot of accessories.

However, if you’ll be using your pot or skillet for serving purposes, you might want to buy a trivet that matches your pot size well. This tool will ensure that no harm will come to your tabletop while serving.

Cast iron-made Dutch ovens are exceptional when it comes to heat retention, meaning that they can destroy your tabletop while serving. Additionally, get thick potholders and a great lid lifter to keep you safe while handling the pot.

Final Verdict

As you’ve already seen from the above discussion, Dutch ovens are incredibly essential cookware that every kitchen needs to have. They are highly versatile, and you can easily use them to prepare almost any meal.

They often have excellent heat retention and distribution capability, making them perfect for slow cooking, and can easily be used on any stovetop.

If you are having a hard time buying one, pick one from our list of 10 best Dutch pots in 2021. In case none of them befits your needs and wants, feel free to use our buying guide in identifying your personal best.

Reference links

  1. https://www.everythingkitchens.com/choose-the-best-dutch-oven.html#
  2. https://www.southerncastiron.com/dutch-oven-buying-guide/

Leave a Comment